# Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company is an Insurance based in Fort Wayne, United States.

## Overview

- **Organization type:** Insurance
- **Headquarters:** Fort Wayne, United States
- **Region:** North America
- **Address:** 6400 Brotherhood Way, Fort Wayne, IN 46825, United States
- **Founded:** 1917
- **Assets under management:** Undisclosed
- **Website:** brotherhoodmutual.com
- **LinkedIn:** https://www.linkedin.com/company/brotherhood-mutual-insurance-company
- **Wikidata:** Q39058788

## Regulatory record

- **Reports private funds:** No

## About

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company was established in 1917. Mark A. Robison holds the roles of Chairman, President, and CEO. The company originated from the Fellowship of Evangelical Churches. The insurer focuses on property and liability products. It maintains an investment portfolio in Fort Wayne. Coverage targets churches and related ministries. Alliances exist with the Southern Baptist Convention and GuideStone Financial Resources. The firm employs named executives including Matthew G. Hirschy as Senior Vice President and Treasurer. It operates Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc. as a separate philanthropic vehicle. Headquarters sit at 6400 Brotherhood Way, Fort Wayne, IN. The company participates in industry groups such as URMIA and the Missouri Insurance Coalition. Its structure centers on insurance underwriting with an adjacent investment book and foundation.

## Sectors

- Insurance

## People

- Mark A. Robison — Chairman, President, and CEO
- Matthew G. Hirschy — Senior Vice President and Treasurer

## Questions

### Who runs investment decisions at Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company?

Mark A. Robison serves as Chairman, President, and CEO. Matthew G. Hirschy holds the role of Senior Vice President and Treasurer.

### What does Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company underwrite?

The company provides property and liability insurance to churches and related ministries.

### Does Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company maintain a foundation?

Yes. Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc. operates as its philanthropic vehicle.

### Where is Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company headquartered?

The firm is based at 6400 Brotherhood Way, Fort Wayne, IN 46825.

### Which organizations partner with Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company?

Alliances include the Southern Baptist Convention and GuideStone Financial Resources for insurance distribution.

## Related profiles

- [Brose Ventures](https://altss.com/profile/brose-ventures)
- [Brouwer & Janachowski](https://altss.com/profile/brouwer-janachowski)

---

Last updated: 2026-06-03T20:00:00.000Z

Canonical page: https://altss.com/profile/brotherhood-mutual-insurance-company

Maintained by Altss — https://altss.com — methodology: https://altss.com/methodology