# Church Mutual Insurance Company

Church Mutual Insurance Company is an Insurance based in Merrill, United States.

## Overview

- **Organization type:** Insurance
- **Headquarters:** Merrill, United States
- **Region:** North America
- **Address:** 3000 Schuster Lane, Merrill, WI 54452, United States
- **Founded:** 1897
- **Assets under management:** Undisclosed
- **Website:** churchmutual.com
- **LinkedIn:** https://www.linkedin.com/company/church-mutual

## Regulatory record

- **Reports private funds:** No

## About

Church Mutual Insurance Company was established in 1897. Alan S. Ogilvie serves as its current President and Chief Executive Officer. The company focuses on property and casualty coverage for churches and related religious entities. The firm holds a bond portfolio and cash and short-term investments, both located in the United States. It operates additional offices in Milwaukee. Church Mutual belongs to the American Property Casualty Insurance Association and the National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies. CM CARES functions as the company's philanthropic foundation. Richard V. Poirier, former CEO, now acts as Senior Advisor. John 'Jay' Williams chairs the board. The mutual corporate form creates direct alignment between policyholders and ownership, distinguishing it from stock insurance companies.

## Sectors

- Insurance

## Offices

- 833 E. Michigan Street, Milwaukee, WI 53202, United States

## People

- Alan S. Ogilvie — President and Chief Executive Officer
- Richard V. Poirier — Senior Advisor
- John 'Jay' Williams — Chairman of the Board of Directors
- Pam Rushing — Chief Operating Officer

## Questions

### Who runs investment decisions at Church Mutual Insurance Company?

Alan S. Ogilvie serves as President and Chief Executive Officer. The firm maintains a bond portfolio and cash holdings in the United States.

### What is Church Mutual Insurance Company's primary line of business?

The company underwrites commercial property and liability insurance for religious organizations.

### Does Church Mutual Insurance Company operate additional offices?

Yes. It maintains an office at 833 E. Michigan Street, Milwaukee, WI 53202.

### What industry associations does Church Mutual Insurance Company belong to?

It participates in the American Property Casualty Insurance Association and the National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies.

### How is Church Mutual Insurance Company structured?

It operates as a mutual insurance company, aligning policyholder and ownership interests.

## Related profiles

- [Churchill Management Group](https://altss.com/profile/churchill-management-group)
- [Church of Scotland Investors Trust](https://altss.com/profile/church-of-scotland-investors-trust)

---

Last updated: 2026-06-03T20:00:00.000Z

Canonical page: https://altss.com/profile/church-mutual-insurance-company

Maintained by Altss — https://altss.com — methodology: https://altss.com/methodology